The Microsoft Surface Laptop Studio Review: Dynamic Designby Brett Howse on October 5, 2021 9:00 AM EST
- Posted in
- Surface Laptop Studio
I was a big fan of the Surface Book. The idea of having a detachable display – which means the main parts of the computer were behind the display – was unique in the high-end PC space. Utilizing the keyboard base for extra battery and a GPU meant that the Surface Book was not just a tablet with an attachable keyboard. It was a powerful notebook, with a great design.
That design, unfortunately, had some compromises to contend with. As a notebook, the Surface Book did not have the same balance as a traditional laptop computer; thanks to the main components of the laptop being located behind the display, the convertible laptop was top-heavy. Microsoft was able to counter this with a unique hinge design which would roll out when opening the device, which extended the base and made the laptop less prone to tipping backwards. Also, having the dGPU in the base gave it much more room for cooling, which improved GPU performance, but since you cannot just disconnect an active GPU from a program without crashing it, it caused some usability quirks with the detach mechanism.
So far as interesting and unique as the Surface Book was, it was clear that there were some challenges with the design that could not be overcome.
Enter the Surface Laptop Studio, which takes the idea of a powerful convertible notebook, and addresses the usability issues to make it a much more fluid experience. Thanks to the dynamic woven hinge, Surface Laptop Studio gets the convenience and usability of a convertible design, but without the traditional drawbacks. Microsoft is not the first to have a display be able to be tilted and folded into a tablet-like experience, but their new hinge is the most elegant solution yet and eliminates almost all the drawbacks of a convertible.
Taking a closer look at the display there are some subtle-yet-wonderful design touches. Microsoft has gone with a radius design on all the exterior corners, and that same radius is matched on the LCD itself. This is a nice touch and fits in well with the new UI aesthetic of Windows 11. The display bezels are not small by the standards of today, but they are dramatically smaller than the outgoing Surface Book. I also like that Microsoft chose to keep the bezels consistent on all sides, rather than tiny on the sides are large on the top and bottom to accommodate the webcam.
In regards to the webcam, probably no laptop component has become as necessary with the prolific rise of video conferencing, and Microsoft has outfitted the Surface Laptop Studio with a 1080p webcam which also supports Windows Hello 2.0 IR. Windows Hello 2.0 is what you would expect, with faster recognition and quicker unlocks, and is apparently better at recognizing you even with some of your face obscured by sunglasses or facial hair. In my limited experience with the Surface Laptop Studio, the Windows Hello worked flawlessly in all tested conditions and regardless of lighting.
Microsoft has created the chassis of the Surface Laptop Studio with a unique step design. The base is slightly smaller than the keyboard deck and features cooling holes on both sides. The fan design puts the fans at the front, which draws cool air on from the back and expels the hot air out the front sides. The step design also provides the perfect spot to store the new Surface Slim Pen 2, which can be magnetically docked on the sides or the front, which also charges the pen. It is a smart design.
Speaking of smart touches, the first time you tile the display forward, the Laptop Studio automatically launches a short video explaining how to utilize the device, and it ends with a demo of where to dock the pen. Once you dock a pen (assuming you buy one) it will then move to pairing it automatically. It is a well thought out experience which will make first time users more easily get the most out of the design.
The new Surface Slim Pen 2 has also been improved in terms of latency and responsiveness. A newly designed digitizer offers higher sensitivity, meaning even less contact is needed before the pen starts to register. The pen still offers an eraser on the opposite end, as well as a haptic button. The carpenter’s pencil shape works well in the hand for writing, although I am curious to see how artists feel about the new design compared to the outgoing Surface Pen. It also does not appear that you can change the tip anymore either. But the fact that it does dock to the device will likely sway most people to its design. The new pen is also compatible on older devices, although not with the same levels of latency. The new Slim Pen 2 when used with the Surface Laptop Studio offers latency down to 12 ms, compared to 25 ms on the older Slim Pen (1).
Microsoft has upped their game in the experience department again with a new keyboard design which they are saying is the best they have ever put on a notebook. After using it, it is hard to argue, The Surface Book offered a fantastic keyboard as well, but the mechanical clicking action of the new Laptop Studio is definitely a step above. Also, they have made the key caps themselves a darker color than the body, unlike the Surface Book’s monochrome look, and that dramatically improves the contrast of the keys when using the white backlighting. The key caps are slightly dished, which lets you get a better perch on them with your fingertips.
Also new is the first ever haptic touchpad on a Surface device. In years past, Microsoft has provided some of the best touchpads for PC laptops, and with the Surface Laptop Studio they have widened the gap further. The trackpad is smooth and responsive, and the haptic feedback does a wonderful simulation of the old-school click without having to have a moving trackpad. It of course supports multi-finger gestures as well, and both the trackpad and haptic feedback are adjustable in the settings.
Microsoft has held onto USB Type-A for so long that it is almost surprising to see it completely removed on the new Surface Laptop Studio, but the inclusion of two Thunderbolt 4 ports should ease the pain. The best part about Thunderbolt 4 is not that you have a very high speed I/O interface, but that Intel has done the right thing and ensured that Thunderbolt 4 supports all options on Type-C. There is no question of does this port support display or charging or whatever. It does it all and will open up a much better docking experience than the USB-based docking of Microsoft docks.
Overall, the design of the Surface Laptop Studio is fantastic. The build quality is fantastic, and the design touches such as the radiused corners also being on the LCD are a great touch. Microsoft has improved their keyboard and trackpad as well, and it was already one of the best in the PC industry. The Surface Laptop Studio packs all the performance of the Surface Book and more and does it while also eliminating some of the pain points on the Book’s unique design, and while coming in smaller, and lighter. It is hard to see how this is not a win on all sides.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
nico_mach - Wednesday, October 6, 2021 - linkI don't think you'll get a clear statement from MS. That said, they indicated that this is the successor, so I wouldn't count on another Book release.
And, yes, that is all they said, there is no definitive 'The Book is dead' statement anywhere.
Daeros - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkJust curious as to why no comparisons were made to other ‘H’ sku offerings from Intel and AMD, or the Apple M1.
It seems like a no-brainer that a CPU with >2x thermal dissipation and external GPU is faster than the ~15w platforms in this review.
Brett Howse - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkHi Daeros. I've not been sampled the Apple M1 in a laptop so it is not in our database.
Most of the "H" series we've tested are bigger gaming systems with much larger GPUs. This is called an H35 but really it's more of a U-series with some headroom.
That being said, feel free to compare the Laptop Studio against any other device we've tested in our online Bench database here:
ingwe - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkSo perhaps a stupid question: based on what I see from the battery life and charge time page, charging only happens through the Surface Connect port and not through Thunderbolt at all? Correct? If so, that is annoying as it means a normal Thunderbolt dock is next to worthless with this.
Brett Howse - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkThe charger that comes with it is the normal Surface one but that doesn't mean you can't charge over the other ports.
rogantastic - Wednesday, October 6, 2021 - linkI picked up my Surface Laptop Studio yesterday and confirmed you can charge with any standard PD charger over Type C on both ports, this is a requirement to be called "Thunderbolt" if less than 120 watts I believe (I could be wrong on the wattage number). I have a 65 Watt PD charger and it works GREAT.
ikjadoon - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkExcellent battery life for a 56 WHr 35W GPU + ~35W dGPU; these idles states are working well.
And great to see, from the surface, a quite decent SSD (as I don't think SK Hynix makes QLC or DRAMless SSDs, do they?).
But, *quite* disappointed to see not a single type-A port and a silly, selfish omission. Following Apple's worse trends: "$1600 MSRP system with a dGPU and not a single USB type-A port."
The oddities are those browser benchmarks.
Either Windows 11, Edge, or some system timers are either beyond amazing or beyond borked. That 192 Speedometer 2.0 score for an i7-11370H (4.8 GHz Turbo) is 34% faster than AnandTech's CPU Bench all-time record of 143 by the i9-11900K (5.3 GHz Turbo).
Also would've liked an M1 comparison at least for battery life or CPU performance, though the main seller here is the hinged touchscreen.
ikjadoon - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - link* 35W CPU
* Apple's worst
SirDragonClaw - Wednesday, October 6, 2021 - linkNo one needs a old usb type-a port these days. Leaving it on would be foolish.
alanh - Tuesday, October 5, 2021 - linkI find it curious that you talk about the new "unique hinge design" and then neglect to include any detailed pics of the hinge on the "Design" page.